Why Our New Year’s Resolutions Are Doomed Before We Even Begin – And What We Can Do About It

Wrinkled Crumbpled PaperWelcome to the end of the first week in January, the week where more  New Year’s resolutions are broken than any other.  According a study conducted in 200225% of New Year’s resolutions are broken in the first week alone. Regular readers may recall similar results of people abandoning projects when we discussed strategies for staying motivated when passion fades.  In that article we cited two studies – one that showed 80% of gym goers drop out within 8 weeks, and another which surveyed over 4 million blogs, and found a quarter were abandoned after only one post.

The good news is that the very act of resolving to do something increases the likelihood of succes – that same study found that,  after 6 months, those who set a resolution were 10 times more likely to stick to their resolution than the non setters (46% versus 4%).  That’s great news for many of my friends, who have publicly committed on their blogs to New Year’s resolution and goals.  Over and over I see many of the same themes:

  • New Year’s resolutions to get in shape
  • New Year’s resolutions to eat better
  • New Year’s resolutions to give up smoking

I have no doubt many of them will be successful.   I’ve already discussed the importance of writing down goals, and absolutely believe that increases the likelihood of success.  Having the support and social pressure from friends is another kick in the right direction.  There’s one thing that has been missing from the discussions I’ve seen online however – how to balance these new resolutions with our prior commitments.

Committing to Change – When We’re Already Overcomitted

Buried Alive OvercommittedI believe a major cause of people failing to accomplish their resolutions is making these new commitments, without first giving up other commitments.  Consider this – if we are already pressed for time for our current commitments, how will we squeeze in time for any of our new ones?  Perhaps it is different for other people, but for me, I already have enough things I want to do.  I have enough goals, so I don’t need new resolutions – but why not take this opportunity to sharpen my focus, and give up on a few things?  Rather than taking on more, I will commit to doing less.

The simplest way I’ve found of letting go is a wonderful concept introduced in Getting Things Done (GTD), the @Someday list.  Very briefly, the @Someday list is my list of items that I intend to get to “Someday.”  Every week or two, I review the items on that list, and if I decide I am ready to begin a project that week, I move it from @Someday into my normal day-to-day GTD system.

I can hear the question  now – if it’s on your @Someday list and it never gets done, what’s the point? The point is, if you don’t explicitly decide what is on your @Someday list, you implicitly put everything you aren’t actively working on on it. Do you have a dream of running a marathon?  Starting your own business? Writing a book? If you don’t actively take action on it right now it’s easy to make excuses and continue to push it off into the nebulous future.  Each week it’ll be something different, but the excuses will probably sound something like this – “Well, I need to first get my taxes squared away, and I want to make sure we have time to remodel the kitchen, and I really wanted to catch a movie this weekend…”. And then while those exact same things may not happen next week, you can be sure something will come up – because why should our later weeks be any less busy?  What gives us the confidence to say that we’ll have less incoming in the future than we have today?  If we don’t actively stifle the other commitments coming into our lives, we’ll become totally overwhelmed with all the inputs.  We’ll continue to put things off, telling ourselves the timing just isn’t right, and we’ll get started on it right after we reach the next arbitrary milestone – this summer, when I’m out of school. Next year, after that promotion. I

“If we wait for the moment when everything, absolutely everything is ready, we shall never begin.”
- Ivan Sergeyevich Turgenev

My New Year’s Dissolutions

Blue Balloon Freedom

So, here is my shot at making this moment more ready for myself.  Today I announce to you my New Year’s dissolutions.:  Tasks that need to fall by the wayside, (or into the someday bucket), to make room for what I truly desire and enjoy, and want to accomplish immediately.

More is not better, and stopping something is often 10 times better than finishing it. Develop the habit of nonfinishing that which is boring or unproducitive if a boss isn’t demanding it.
- Tim Ferris, Four-Hour Work Week, page 88

Mixx Button

Sid’s New Year Dissolutions

  • Give up on reading some of the non-fiction books on my shelf.  I have some half finished books that I feel I “should” read.  No need to anymore.  I’m letting those commitments go.
  • Reduce professional metawork. I spent many hours these past few years listening to various software development podcasts (The Java Posse, Java Rant, Pragmatic Podcasts, Stack Overflow) and reading technical websites and blogs.  The experts that produce this content are top notch, and I recommend every one of those podcasts.  In my own life, however, many of the things I learned were never applied – yet I have  a constant internal yearning to make sure I keep up.  From here on out I’ll stay up to date as time permits, but if I miss a week, or two, or a month – it’s ok. I give myself permission to skip the podcasts and software development websites.
  • Further reduce self inflicted junk mail.  I’ve been pretty good about this, but there are still certain email lists I haven’t had the heart to unsubscribe from, and friends that I haven’t wanted to mark as spam.
  • No longer keep up with new music.  I love music.  I used to go to over 50 concerts a year and have always enjoyed a variety of artists – folk, rock, rap, you name it. Lately though, it’s felt like work for me to keep up with all the new music out there - and I won’t try to anymore. I won’t know all the cool indie bands – and I’m ok with that.
  • Leave items unread in Google Reader.  I’ve often prided myself on how quickly I read and absorb RSS feeds.  It’s time to separate out what’s productive however, and what I’m doing just out of a sense of responsibilit, entertainmenty and pride for completeness – I don’t need to read everything, everyday.  I have already separated out the 5-10% of items that provide the most value to me, and have unsubscribed from various sites that provide less (Digg, TechCrunch, and Slashdot are among the more notable that I’ve stopped reading).  As Tim Ferris notes in The Four-Hour Work Week if the news is that important, it’ll find it’s way to me (page 84) – and if it’s not, what’s the harm in not reading it?  As an aside, I’ve been having some fun the past couple days – I read the most important couple of folders in my reader, and skim through most of the rest – when I get to the last 20-30%, I just mark all as read and skip them.

How about you – want to make a New Year’s dissolution?

Get On The List and Get Your Free Course and Ebook!

Personal Development 101 Cover
  • Your free personal development course, Personal Development 101
  • Instant updates when new articles get published
  • Your free copy of The Little Book Of Big Motivational Quotes

Enter Your Email Address Now:


Did you know ... this list of articles is custom generated for you? If you enjoyed this article, you may enjoy these similar articles:

  1. Reflection Questions – The Most Important Questions You’ll Answer This Year
  2. The Seven Rules Of New Year’s Resolutions
Please review the Comment Policy.
  • "I can hear the question now - if it’s on your @Someday list and it never gets done, what’s the point? The point is, if you don’t explicitly decide what is on your @Someday list, you implicitly put everything you aren’t actively working on on it."

    Very true. Knowing the difference between things that aren't worth thinking about now and things that aren't worth thinking about at all is a crucial skill. The @Someday list gives you a placeholder to keep potential commitments conscious.

    This is why "dissolutions" are so important. When we take on a new project, we don't do so in a vacuum. We need to not only want to do something, but want it enough to not to something else. I found myself suffering from time famine until I did an activity analysis and realized how much gratuitous reading I was indulging in during the week, so I made a rule to batch all of my discretionary reading for Sunday. No books, magazines, blogs, etc. That one dissolution freed up so much time that for the first couple of days, I sometimes didn't know what to do with myself.

    If you're going to make a resolution, try to define when and where working on it needs to happen, then see what habitual activities you can prune to make space for it.
  • Hi Andre,
    That's wonderful. I agree that sitting at a computer, I could waste hours
    every day if I wanted to. Just like you, I try and batch my online reading
    - though I'm not yet at once a week =)

    "freed up so much time that for the first couple of days, I sometimes didn't
    know what to do with myself"

    This is a point Tim Ferris brings up in the Four Hour Work Week as well -
    initially it is hard to pull away from being "busy" (checking email, reading
    online, etc etc) but perhaps what is even more difficult is once we pull
    away from it, finding activities that are meaningful and enriching to fill
    that time.
  • I haven't read Tim Ferris' book but I've heard enough people talk about it, I already know what it's about. Your reference to whatever on page 84 is something I read on Dan Schawbel's blog several months ago relating to the concept of "social proof." If enough people talk about something, you hear it, too. Hence, goodbye Techcrunch (though I hear Techcrunch UK is better).

    But to the heart of your post: What is a new year's resolution in the first place and why must you make one? There was an article at the Brazen Careerist in the final days of December with the takeaway that you can make a resolution any day of the year. But do you?
  • Hi Ari,
    Tim Ferris was absolutely everywhere online when his book came out - it
    seemed like half the blogs I read had a review!

    I definitely agree - why not have spring resolutions, winter resolutions?
    ;)

    I think *one* benefit of having a new year's resolution though is people
    seem to be more supportive of life changes during January, specifically for
    that reason - everyone's doing it. On the other hand, imagine trying to
    start a diet during Thanksgiving - socially less acceptable, and surely
    pulled in different directions by competing social/family demands.
  • Great thoughts there Sid. It reminds me of the "no thank you" and "not-to-do" list discussed by John Maxwell and Stephen Covey in some of their books. Other themes that I noticed people mention, even though not in their blogs, is to get their financial position in better shape. On your "dissolution" list. I know a lot of folks would love to do #2 if they are only better in managing time/commitments.
  • Hi Busby,
    You're right, I can understand many people wish they had more time to keep
    up with their field and stay up to date with new developments. I think
    technical fields such as software development in particular have a problem
    with too much information - not only is tons of information produced, but
    the knowledge gained goes out of date so quickly. If I don't apply it, in 6
    months it's obsolete - at which point I wonder, why did I waste any time
    reading about it? =)
  • Hi Sid. I agree with you. I tried working around that by learning only those where I intend to teach or conduct a seminar later on. It has made the learning experience more targeted.
  • For me, I am still stick to my old resolutions which I wrote down 4 years ago. I look at it everyday and recite it 50 times a days.
  • Hi Hamdani,

    That's wonderful! I am guessing you must have it taped up or written
    somewhere that you can refer to easily and frequently =)
  • Love the idea of "dissoulutions." I've called these posteriorities rather than priorities because they need to be moved to the back of the line! Start each day with 5 things you won't do and 5 things you will!
  • Haha! Nice one Ron. Love the word. I like the idea of picking 5 things you
    won't do today. Definitely see the value in it - review tasks, and decide
    which ones you won't do right then, rather than feeling bad at the end of
    the day when you couldn't get through it all!
  • Great idea: "dissolutions." I call this "disengaging."

    Another great idea: A "burn box." Lets you disengage from paper without actually throwing it away. Take an empty box, throw stuff into if if you might ever need it. Throw away the bottom half of the box any time it fills up. Gives you 2-3 months to change your mind about anything, so you're not afraid to toss stuff. This is one tip shared in my company's customizable online time management training system (you can sign up free).

    Kevin Crenshaw
    http://www.priacta.com/Training/troonline.php
    Hope this helps!
  • Hi Kevin,
    I like that concept of the burn box - I guess my only concern (like everyone
    else) is what if the time frame isn't long enough and you need something the
    day after. I definitely see the value in it though. Perhaps I'll check out
    Priacta and see what it's all about - although I won't commit to trying
    anything new just yet ;)
  • The idea of New Year's "Dissolutions" strikes me as a sound one, and I've already purged my Google Reader, working on the email junk mail one...

    I think a lot of these information-overload life-clutter things happen in large part because of a sense of not wanting to "miss out"; the persistent delusion that there's one perfect shining piece of golden information out there that -- if we can only catch and absorb that nugget as it sails by!! -- will make all the difference & make sudden sense of all the rest of the bits of our lives. With that theory in mind, I'm resolving to "dissolve" and downsize my information intake in 2009.
  • Haha. It's an annual ritual - year round, discover cool new blogs, add them
    to your reader - and at year end, look at your reader and wonder, why do I
    read all this stuff?

    I definitely have that tension you describe of not wanting to miss out. I
    considered hiring an assistant to sort through all my reading, tried out
    AideRSS/Postrank etc - but *still* didn't find anything that quite was
    enough to make me feel at ease. I guess part of the problem is just because
    the general population likes something doesn't mean I will - and just
    because the general population doesn't, doesn't mean I prefer to ignore it
    either!

    StumbleUpon is probably the best solution I have found - if it's good, and I
    have a good network of friends and people I follow, with similar interests
    to mine, eventually it will find it's way to me and I will read it =).
  • Brilliant! I especially like the one about reducing self-inflicted junk mail. I'd add to that to reduce any kind of junk mail. It's the "green" thing to do. :)

    Thanks for sharing your thoughts!

    Small Footprints
    http://reducefootprints.blogspot.com
  • Good point! I don't get as much junk mail as most people (in fact, I hardly
    get any). I'm not sure why, perhaps someone has flagged me on a list as a
    person who never responds and isn't worth marketing to =)

    I know there are various companies that, for a fee, will remove you from
    direct marketing mailing lists. I can't vouch for them myself, perhaps I'll
    review some in the future
  • "No longer keep up with new music"
    Once every 6 months or so I use amazons "recommend for you" to find new albums that I would have missed. I then batch get the albums and have them ready to listen to. The whole process takes maybe a hour and considering all the good stuff that's touched my life I'd missed, I'll take it =]
  • That's a great idea Steve! I love Amazon's recommendation engine as well.

    Sounds to me like you've figured out how to distill months of music
    listening and sorting into a single, batch processed task - and used amazon
    to outsource the work of actually filtering through the music!

    I enjoy using Amazon for the same reason, I used to enjoy constantly being
    on top of everything - I think i'll give your approach a try, maybe in a
    couple months instead of 6 =). I definitely don't want to give up music
    altogether either!
  • If you were stranded on a desert island with nothing but you and nature, you'd have to stop smoking because there would be nothing to smoke. So people *can* stop smoking. They just have to *want it*. I think far too many people set New Years resolutions that they don't really want to achieve. They know they should set them because achieving them would mean a better life (no smoking, better eating etc), but deep down I don't really think they want to stop smoking or eat better because they enjoy both those things.

    As for my dissolutions, I'd probably say TV is my biggest time waster. I spent about 40 hours a wake watching the likes of The Simpsons, CSI, NCIS, Sport and cooking programmes. Entertaining and fun, sure. Productive? Nope!

    Thanks for the very interesting post, Sid. It's nice to see you back after the holiday break!

    Jamie
  • Sorry. That was meant to say 40 hours a week. Doh! :-)

    Jamie
  • Too bad, I kind of liked 40 hours awake a week...
  • Definitely agree - there's a difference between truly desiring to change,
    and just saying you want to change. I'm sure there are many "social
    resolvers" (hehe) - people who don't really want to change their lives, but
    make resolutions because everyone else is.
    Thanks for the welcome back...to my own blog ;) Hehe